Common Mistakes to Avoid When

This question helps you understand the agency’s unique value proposition. Every agency claims to be “the best,” but this question forces them to articulate what makes their services stand out. For example:

• Do they specialize exclusively in legal marketing, or do they work across multiple industries?
• Do they have proprietary tools, methodologies, or certifications that give them an edge?
• Are they known for innovative strategies, exceptional customer service, or measurable results?

In the context of a law firm, you want an agency that understands the legal industry’s nuances—such as compliance with advertising regulations, the importance of trust-building, and the competitive nature of local SEO.

Not all law firms are the same. A small personal injury practice will have very different needs compared to a large corporate law firm or a boutique estate planning practice. This question ensures that the agency has relevant experience working with firms like yours. Key points to consider:

• Have they worked with solo practitioners, mid-sized firms, or large multi-office practices?
• Do they understand the challenges and opportunities specific to your practice area (e.g., criminal defense, family law, intellectual property)?
• Can they provide case studies or testimonials from past clients in the legal field?

An agency with prior experience in your niche will likely require less ramp-up time and deliver better results faster.

Digital marketing is data-driven, so it’s crucial to align on how success will be defined and measured. Asking about Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) ensures transparency and accountability. Common KPIs for law firms include:

• Website traffic (organic vs. paid)
• Conversion rates (e.g., form submissions, phone calls, consultations booked)
• Cost per lead (CPL) or cost per acquisition (CPA)
• Return on Investment (ROI)
• Rankings for targeted keywords
• Social media engagement metrics

By clarifying these metrics upfront, you can avoid misunderstandings later and ensure the agency focuses on outcomes that matter most to your firm.

This question addresses the level of attention and expertise your account will receive. Will you be assigned a dedicated account manager, or will your project be handed off to junior staff? Points to explore:

• What is the background and experience level of the person managing your account?
• How accessible will they be for updates, questions, or strategy adjustments?
• Will there be a single point of contact, or will you deal with multiple team members?

For law firms, having a reliable and knowledgeable account manager is essential because legal marketing often involves nuanced discussions about compliance, messaging, and campaign goals.

The tools an agency uses can significantly impact the quality and efficiency of their work. This question helps you assess whether they leverage modern, cutting-edge technologies or rely on outdated methods. Examples of tools to inquire about include:

• SEO platforms (e.g., SEMrush, Ahrefs, Moz)
• PPC management software (e.g., Google Ads, Microsoft Advertising)
• Analytics tools (e.g., Google Analytics, Hotjar)
• CRM systems for lead tracking and nurturing (e.g., HubSpot, Salesforce)
• Content creation and design tools (e.g., Adobe Creative Suite, Canva)

Agencies that invest in advanced tools are often better equipped to optimize campaigns and deliver superior results.

Legal marketing is heavily regulated, and failing to comply with state bar association rules can result in fines, sanctions, or reputational damage. This question ensures the agency understands and respects these regulations. Specific areas to discuss:

• Are they familiar with the American Bar Association (ABA) Model Rules of Professional Conduct?
• How do they ensure ad copy, website content, and social media posts comply with ethical guidelines?
• Do they have a process for reviewing and revising materials flagged for non-compliance?

For law firms, partnering with an agency that prioritizes compliance is non-negotiable.

Finally, this question allows you to validate the agency’s claims through third-party feedback. Speaking directly with past or current clients gives you insight into:

• The quality of the agency’s work
• Their communication style and responsiveness
• Whether they delivered on promises and met expectations
• Any challenges or issues encountered during the partnership

References serve as social proof and can help you make a more informed decision.

These seven questions collectively cover the most important aspects of evaluating a digital marketing agency: their expertise, approach, tools, communication, and ability to meet your firm’s unique needs. By asking these questions, you’re not only gathering information but also setting clear expectations for the partnership.

For law firms, where trust and credibility are paramount, choosing the wrong agency can have serious consequences—from wasted budgets to damaged reputations. On the flip side, selecting the right partner can lead to sustained growth, increased visibility, and a steady stream of qualified leads.